Can You Weld Cast Iron? – (A Complete Guide)

Welding cast iron is possible, but it has challenges due to the high carbon levels in cast iron. This is typically around 2-4%, roughly ten times that of most steels.

Due to the losses during welding the carbon can either migrate into the weld metal and/or the heat affected zone which ramps up the brittleness/hardness, and can eventually lead to cracking occurring post weld.

Cast iron is primarily iron and carbon in different proportions, with other alloying elements added such as manganese, silicon, chromium, nickel, copper, molybdenum, etc., for certain properties.

It can contain significantly more sulfur and phosphorus than is acceptable as impurity when it comes to the welding process with potnetially having a negatuve effect to cause cracking.

The various types of cast iron with different degrees of weldability are gray cast irons, white cast irons, ductile (nodular) irons, malleable irons, etc.

All types of cast iron except white iron is considered “weldable” even though welding cast iron is certainly easier than welding any mild or carbon steel.

The problem we face, is it is often difficult to distinguish between the types of cast iron just by looking at them without very detailed metallurgical analysis. Regardless, cast irons are a durable and wear resistant material that has been utilized for thousands of years.

Pre-Welding Steps for Cast Iron

Four key steps should be taken before getting started to ensure the effective welding of cast iron. These include:

• Determining the Type of Cast Iron
• Cleaning the Cast
• Selecting the Correct Pre-Heat Temperature
• Choosing the Right Welding Technique

1. Determining the Type of Cast Iron

To begin the process of researching welding cast iron, the initial step is identifying the type of cast iron, as there are plenty of types and there are many types that you will not want to weld.

Cast iron generally has low ductility and has the potential to crack due to thermal stresses when heated up or cooled down very fast.

The potential for cracking is dependent on the type and/or classification of the cast iron. It is therefore important to understand what specific type of alloy you are dealing with:

• Grey Cast Iron: It is the most prevalent type of cast iron. During the casting process, carbon precipitates as the carbon phases into graphite flakes depending on whether they end up in a pearlite or ferrite crystal matrix. Compared to white cast iron, grey cast iron is more ductile and has better weldability, however, it does provide challenges to future welders because the carbon flakes of grey cast iron can be pull into the weld pool and become a source of weld metal embrittlement.
• White Cast Iron: White cast iron precipitates the carbon as iron carbide, it does not precipitate the carbon as graphite. The cementite crystal structure is extremely brittle and hard, so it is generally deemed unweldable.
• Ductile, nodular, or malleable iron: These cast irons are all less brittle than grey and white cast irons because their microstructures are a result of manufacture. All three have spheroidal carbon microstructures due to the manufacture of these cast irons.

The easiest way to identify the type of iron you are using is to contact the producer or review the original specification. Chemical and metallographic analysis can point to the classification of cast iron you are working with, as well.

There are other ways to distinguish between iron alloys, grey iron will exhibit a gray color in addition to a fracture point, whereas white iron will show an even whiter color preferably along a fracture due to the cementite in the white iron.

On the other hand, ductile iron, for example, will also show a lighter color along the fracture point but is much more well situated for welding.

Gray cast iron is the most common type of cast iron welded and is the only cast iron you should attempt to weld unless you are experienced with casting or welding cast iron. Having someone experienced to help you do it is a better option.

2. Clean the casting

All castings, irrespective of alloy, should be adequately pre-weld prepared before a weld repair can be made. While preparation for welding, it is very important that all surface materials are removed. The casting must be totally clean in the weld area.

Remove paint, grease, oil, and any other foreign matter, from the weld area. It is best to impose heat carefully and slowly on the weld area for a short time in order to eliminate entrap gases from the weld area of the base metal.

A very simple method to test the condition of the cast iron surface is to make a weld pass on the metal—if there are any contaminants, it will be porous. This weld pass can be grinded off and the procedure cans be repeated after pre-weld cleaning, until the porosity is gone.

3. Pre-Heat Temperature

All cast irons are vulnerable to cracking under stress. Heat control is the single most important factor in avoiding cracks.

A cast-iron weld requires three steps:

• Pre-heating
• Low heat input
• Slow cooling

The principal motive for thermal control is thermal expansion. Metal expands when it becomes warm. There is no stress when a part heats uniformly. However, there will be stress created when the heat is localized to small heat-affected zones (HZ).

Localized heating has limited expansion as the heat affected zone is contained by cooler surrounding metal. The stress created depends on the thermal gradient between the HZ and the casting body.

In steel and other ductile metals, the stress generated by the restricted expansion and contraction is accommodated by the stretching of the metal.

Unfortunately, cast irons have limited ductility, and this may result in cracking during the contraction phase. Pre-heating reduces the thermal gradient between the casting body and HZ, thus reducing the tensile stress induced by the welding.

For a majority of welds, higher temperature welding methods generally require a higher temperature preheat.

If preheating is not possible, then limiting heat input, selecting a low temperature welding process, and low melting point welding rods or wires are the best way to protect the casting.

The cooling rate is one other factor that influences the stresses generated at the weld. Rapid cooling causes contraction and can produce brittle, easy to crack welds. Lower cooling produces less hardening and contraction stresses.

4. Welding Technique Use To Weld Cast Iron

In theory, a common arc welding process such as manual metal arc welding, flux-cored arc welding, metal active gas welding, submerged arc welding, tungsten arc welding, etc. can be used, but a process that allows for a slower rate of heating and cooling will usually be preferred.

1. Manual Metal Arc Welding (MMA)

This electronic arc welding process (also termed shielded metal arc welding (SMAW)) is generally assumed to be the best overall process for cast iron if the correct welding rods are used. Selecting an electrode should include consideration of the application, the required color match and the amount of post-weld machining.

The two types of electrode for manual metal arc welding are iron-based and nickel-based electrodes. An iron-based electrode will yield weld metal with high carbon martensite, thereby generally limiting it to repairs of minor extent of casting or when color matching is a consideration.

Nickel alloy electrodes are the most commonly used electrodes. Nickel electrodes provide a more ductile weld metal. Nickel electrodes can also reduce the pre-heating and HAZ cracking because nickel alloys will result in a lower-strength weld metal.

Regardless of the base metal, every effort should be made to minimize parent metal melting. This is to minimize dilution.

2. MAG Welding

MAG welding is typically performed with a nickel consumable. An 80% argon to 20% carbon dioxide gas mix is suitable for the majority of the applications. While it is more than likely if you chose to use brazing wire, it is not usually recommended as the braze metal will be significantly weaker than the cast.

3. TIG Welding

Although TIG welding can provide a clean weld on cast iron, it is not recommended due to the localized heating qualities of the process. TIG welding is no different than any other welding process; the quality of the finished weld is heavily based on the skill of the welder.

4. Oxy-Acetylene Welding

Oxyacetylene welding also uses electrodes. But instead of having an arc produced by an electrical current, oxy-acetylene welding uses an oxy-acetylene torch to provide the energy used for the welding process. In oxy-acetylene welding of cast iron, both cast iron electrodes, and copper-zink electrodes can be used.

It is important that cast iron does not oxidize during the acetylene welding process, due to the loss of silicon and the generation of white iron in the weld.

The welding rod should be melted in the molten weld pool and not immediately by the flame so that the temperature gradients in the weld are kept to a minimum.

5. Braze Welding

Brazewelding is a well-studied method of joining cast iron components primarily due to the limited influence on the base metal it operates on.

A welding rod can be used to simulate a filler on the cast iron surface. The melting point of the filler will be less than the melting point of the cast iron, meaning the filler typically will not be diluted by the cast iron but retained at the surface.

The cleanliness of the surface is of critical importance to this welding process as the quality of the filler wetting the surface of the base metal is critical to the joint. Machine Design describes the use of flux to reduce oxides formed while brazewelding which is common.

Flux is a liquid that assists wetting and allows the filler to flow across the parts to be joined, as well as to clean the parts of unwanted oxides that allow the filler to bond more fully to the metal parts. Fluxes are often used in welding to clean metal surfaces.

Welding Techniques without Preheat

The casting’s size, or other pertinent factors, may dictate that the repair is to be made without preheating. In this case, the part and weld need to be kept at least cool, but not cold.

It is advantageous to raise the temperature of the casting to 100 degrees F. If the part is affixed to an engine, it may be possible to run the engine for a few minutes to accomplish this temperature. It should never be heated too hot to allow you to place your bare hand on it.

Make short welds of approximately 1″ long. The process of peening after welding is crucial with this process. Allow the weld, and the casting, to cool to room temperature, and never use water or compressed air to hasten cooling.

You may be able to weld in another part of the casting while the prior weld is cooling. It is necessary to fill all craters. When possible, have the beads in the same direction, and preferably the ends of parallel beads do not line up one after another.

Filler Wire or Electrode used for Cast welding

As stated previously, in choosing the welding rod to use when welding cast iron is important even though most authorities would agree with using nickel rods.

1. 99% Nickel Rods

The cost of these electrodes is a little higher than other electrodes but are also the highest performing. 99% nickel rods yield welds that can be machined and work best on castings with low or medium phosphorous content. These pure nickel rods yield a soft and malleable weld deposit.

2. 55% Nickel Rods

This is a less expensive alternative to the 99% rods and does allow for machinability while being often used for thick section repairs. With a lower co-efficient expansion, these will produce fewer fusion line cracks than the 99%. Ferro-nickel rods are ideal for welding cast iron to steel.

While there are less expensive alternatives, such as with steel rods, these are not nearly as effective at working like nickel rods:

3. Steel Rods

Among the three possibilities, the steel rods offer the lowest price. It is good for minor repairs and for filling. Steel electrodes make very hard welds that require a lot of grinding to finish, and cannot be ground.

However, some of the benefits of steel rods include a matching color, and better tolerating castings that are not entirely clean, as compared to nickel rods.

4. Brazing bronze

The rods can be used for oxy-acetylene brazing or in a TIG welder. It is a good method to put a strong hold in a crack or between two parts that are having to be mated without cracking and changing the properties of the cast iron.

Cleaning and Peening Weld Surfaces

As with most welding applications, the cleaner the surface is, the easier it is to achieve high quality welds. Often when working with cast iron, the parts you are welding might have had attributed lifetime sheen of fumes or oil in the casting and this could pose issue to you during the welding process. There are things to take account for when welding cast iron.

One of the best way to ensure adequate welds are to select welding consumables, and specifically MG-289 Cast Iron Welding Alloy rods. These consumables are specifically designed for welds in contaminated cast iron making the ultimate in a safe guard to ensure the weld is adequate.

Peening is when you tap the soft weld as it cools, with a ball-peen hammer, to reduce crack formation. You must be careful with peening and only do it when the weld can still deform, but peening is not always necessary, since it is generally only irregular or rapid heating or cooling of the part that cause cracks. The most important thing when working with cast iron is preheating and slow cooling with your project.

Preheat or cold-weld?

Opinions differ on whether to weld hot or cold. Everybody does agree preheating is a good option, but there are a few that recommend welding with little heat is good enough too.

When methods are considered to weld cast iron, one of these methodologies must be taken, as cast iron is brittle and has virtually no ability to deform by bending, expansion, or contractility unlike other metals.

Heat always has a deforming effect on metals, and if one area of the metal changes faster than the other, this results in stress and cracking of the cast iron or weld.

Preheating would help alleviating the affect of this by bringing the surrounding area of the weld to a closer level toward the welding temperatures which allows the whole component to change together when welding cast iron.

Cast iron changes characteristics over about 1400 degree Fahrenheit, so it is very important not to exceed heat limits on the component being welded or repaired.

Welding cast iron in a cool manner, without preheating and with minimal amount of heat, is effective in the sense of lower overall temperature producing no visible cracks, however this weld will be stronger than a hot weld without preheating cast iron, but still internal stress could occur on any weld method that could reveal later on the life of the component and produce an overall weaker weld than if preheated is taken before welding.

A cast iron repair man or cast iron product manufacturer and welder who has extensive experienced, never ever welds cast iron without a good preheat and more importantly, it assures proper strength, internally, in the weld not just externally from visible crackles.

FAQs